In
addition to the negotiations between the Cambodian government and
the U.N. over the composition of the court, Cambodias capacity
to hold fair trials in its courts has been scrutinized in other
ways as well. Various important trials that have taken place in
Cambodian courts over the past several years have been seen as diagnostic.
Khmer Rouge commander Nuon Paet was legitimately convicted and sentenced
to life in prison for his role in the kidnapping deaths of three
foreign tourists in 1994. (However, higher-level Khmer Rouge commanders
implicated in the same murders were never put on trial, and currently
serve in the military.) In 1998, human rights workers who had been
arrested for protesting toxic waste dumping in Sihanoukville, were
subsequently released due to lack of evidence. These trials were
scrutinized by international observers for signs of corruption,
lack of due process, and political influence, leading many to conclude
that the presence of international observers is essential to ensuring
credible trials of Khmer Rouge leaders.
Another approach to boosting the capacity of the Cambodian courts
was that taken by the Cambodian Genocide Program, based at Yale
University and funded in part by the U.S. State Department [www.yale.edu/cgp].
In 1995 and 1996, the Program conducted legal training courses in
Cambodia to improve the ability of Cambodians to pursue and promote
legal remedies for the crimes against humanity they suffered at
the hands of the Khmer Rouge. The participants were about twenty
people from Cambodian human rights organizations, the Cambodian
Ministry of Justice, the Ministry of the Interior, and the Foreign
Ministry, the Council of Ministers, and independent legal advocacy
groups. The course included an introduction to the major sources
of international law, a grounding in human rights law, individual
responsibility under international law, and general principles of
criminal procedure and evidence. The course also covered the two
ad-hoc criminal tribunals for the genocidal crimes committed in
Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia, for the purpose of comparison.
Political dimensions of the process
It was only four years ago that a trial of Khmer Rouge leaders began
to seem possible. In April 1997, nearly twenty years after the genocide,
the United Nations adopted resolution 1997/49, which requested the
Secretary General, through his Special Representative, to examine
any request for assistance in responding to past serious violations
of Cambodian and international law. The Cambodian government followed
with a letter dated June 21, 1997, signed by the then co-Prime Ministers,
Prince Norodom Ranariddh and Hun Sen, requesting the assistance
of the United Nations and the international community in "bringing
to justice those persons responsible for the genocide and crimes
against humanity during the rule of the Khmer Rouge from 1975 to
1979."
|