The
International Humanitarian Fact-Finding Commission (IHFFC) is an
independent, permanent body that owes its existence to Article 90
of Additional Protocol I of 1977. In place since 1991, with its
seat and secretariat at Berne, it is at the disposition of parties
to armed conflicts that suspect, or are suspected of, serious violations
of international humanitarian law (IHL). Although originally created
for international armed conflicts, it holds itself capable to function
in an internal armed conflict as well; a stance to which no government
has objected. The IHFFC considers that it can offer its services
to parties to a conflict without having been invited to do so but
it will take such a step only if it appears prudent.
It is competent to: (1) inquire into alleged serious violations
of IHL; (2) facilitate, through its good offices, the restoration
of respect for IHL. The IHFFC regards the two functions as not necessarily
linked, enabling it to carry out its good offices function independent
of any inquiry (and vice versa). This does justice to their somewhat
different orientations: while an inquiry into alleged violations
may point in the direction of criminal proceedings, good offices
may be conducive not just to the restoration of an attitude of respect
for IHL but for the other party as well.
States may accept the competence of the IHFFC in relation to other
States doing the same, by depositing a declaration to that effect
with the Swiss authorities. At the moment of writing, fifty-three
States have made such declarationsmany of them European (including
from the former Eastern bloc), and one of the UN Security Councils
permanent five, Russia. (Another, the United Kingdom, has announced
its intention to do so soon.) A States acceptance of IHFFC
competence does not bind that State in relation to its opponent
or opponents in an internal armed conflict within its territory.
The fifteen IHFFC members "of high moral standing and acknowledged
impartiality" are elected for five-year terms by the States
that have made such declarations. Since the 1996 elections it is
composed of eleven Europeans (one from Russia) and four from other
continents with the exception of Asia.
For the IHFFC to carry out its functions impartially and effectively
requires the consent of the parties involved. This indispensable
requirement may at the same time be one of the factors why to this
day the IHFFC has remained largely unused.
Frits
Kalshoven is President of the IHFFC.

|