Aggression in international law is defined as the use of
force by one State against another, not justified by self-defense
or other legally recognized exceptions. The illegality of aggression
is perhaps the most fundamental norm of modern international law
and its prevention the chief purpose of the United Nations. Even
before the UN, the League of Nations made the prevention of aggression
a core aim; and the post-World War II Allied tribunals regarded
aggression as a crime under the rubric crimes against peace.
The most authoritative definition comes from the UN General Assembly.
(The UN Charter never defines the term, instead banning the threat
or use of force.) In 1974, it completed a twenty-year project to
define aggression. Member States claimed that a definition would
help the UN—principally the Security Council, charged by the
Charter with addressing aggression—in responding more consistently
and promptly. While it reflects a broad international consensus,
it is not a treaty, though it may represent customary international
law.
The definition begins by stating that “[t]he first use of
armed force by a State in contravention of the Charter” constitutes
prima facie evidence of aggression. The definition is somewhat limiting,
and perhaps circular, in that the first use of force by a State
would not be aggression if undertaken in a way consistent with the
Charter. Thus, for example, the deployment of U.S. forces to Somalia
in 1992, while the first use of force, would not be aggression because
it was authorized by the Security Council under Chapter VII of the
Charter. A number of States have accepted that a State’s first
use of force to extricate its citizens from another State when they
are in imminent danger, and the other State is not able to protect
them, is not aggression (e.g., Israel’s 1976 Entebbe raid)
and may be a form of self-defense. Some scholars and human rights
activists have advocated a broader right of non-UN-approved intervention
to prevent large-scale human rights abuses.
Moreover, most States seem willing to accept, albeit tacitly, a
limited right of a State to a first use of armed force—so-called
anticipatory self-defense—where it is facing a certain, imminent,
and catastrophic attack, such as was faced by Israel on the eve
of the June 1967 war. However, the assertion by the United States
government in its 2002 National Security Strategy of a broader right
of preemptive self-defense to deal with “rogue States and
terrorists” possessing weapons of mass destruction elicited
significant criticism internationally. Foreign governments and others
also condemned the war in Iraq in 2003 in part because they rejected
U.S claims that the action was authorized by prior Security Council
resolutions (the U.S. did not make a legal argument that the war
was taken as a matter of self-defense) and concluded that it was
thus aggression under the Charter.
The General Assembly’s definition also offers an illustrative
list of acts of aggression: invasion, attack, or occupation of whatever
duration; bombardment; blockade; attack on another State’s
armed forces; unauthorized use of military forces stationed in a
foreign State; allowing territory to be used for aggression; and
sending armed bands or similar groups to carry out aggression or
substantial involvement therein.
Acts of aggression such as these trigger the two key lawful uses
of force mentioned in the Charter: (a) individual or collective
self-defense; and (b) force approved by the UN itself. Thus, the
Iraqi invasion of Kuwait triggered the right of Kuwait and its allies
to engage in self-defense, as well as the right of the UN to approve
the use of force against Iraq under Chapter VII.
Despite its prohibition in international law, aggression remains
a feature of international life. Although the classic attack on
another State is not as rampant as before World War II, more subtle
forms of armed intervention persist, and the responses of the international
community remain plagued by timidity and inconsistency.
(See humanitarian intervention;
just and unjust war.)

|