Although
the United Nations has created several special tribunals to
prosecute war crimes around the world, it has not always come
up with the necessary funding and personnel to support war
crimes investigations. Thus, a variety of non-governmental
organizations (NGOs) have begun to assist in the documentation
of violations of international humanitarian law.
Physicians
for Human Rights (PHR) has monitored human rights violations
in more than 20 countries worldwide and made their information
available to war crimes investigators in Croatia, Bosnia,
and Rwanda. In all of these countries, PHR undertook detailed
exhumations of suspected mass graves; in Vukovar, they amassed
evidence which helped lead to the indictment of the Yugoslav
Army officers. In Sanski Most and areas around Srebrenica,
they organized exhumations in an effort to support the activities
of the UN tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY). In addition,
PHR established an antemortem database and collected information
of missing persons from their relatives. These activities,
combined with educational and other local capacity initiatives,
assisted the Bosnian medical authorities in dealing with the
identification of those persons who fell victim to grave violations
of humanitarian law and who have been missing for more than
five years.
In
Sierra Leone, No Peace Without Justice (NPWJ) has been active
in providing legal advice and support to the Government of
Sierra Leone as it formulates the Special Court to try those
persons accused of grave violations of humanitarian law in
the territory of Sierra Leone. As part of the NPWJ Judicial
Assistance Program, legal experts at the United Nations in
New York and at the Field Mission in Sierra Leone have assisted
in negotiating the proposed legal statutes for this Court,
the first of its kind in West Africa
By
far the most extensive support from NGOs in war crimes documentation
took place in Kosovo, where the International Crisis Group
(ICG) was specifically tasked with the field documentation
of war crimes.The methodology, structure, and goals of the
ICG Humanitarian Law Documentation Project set a new precedent
for war crime documentation work. Its mission was comprised
of some 46 international and 123 local staff operating in
Kosovo and Albania for seven months between May and December
1999. ICG researchers collected some 4,700 witness statements
on a CD ROM database and forwarded to the ICTY in Prishtina
and the Hague. This searchable database gave the ICTY an extensive
list of witnesses as well as information on the types of crimes
alleged.
Articles
2,3,4, and 5 of the statute of the ICTY detail the crimes
that the tribunal is charged with investigating in former
Yugoslavia. Article 3 lists the violations of the laws or
customs of war which include the "attack, bombardment,
by whatever means, of undefended towns, villages, dwellings,
or buildings;" and the "plunder of public or private
property". Article 5 deals with Crimes against humanity,
which include "murder; extermination; deportation; torture
and rape." It is under these two articles that Slobodan
Milosevic and leading members of the Yugoslav cabinet have
been indicted.
The
task facing ICTY investigators following the withdrawal of
Yugoslav army, police, and paramilitary units from Kosovo
in June 1999 was on an unprecedented scale. Unlike Bosnia-Herzegovina,
freedom of movement in post-conflict Kosovo was less complicated
and entailed fewer security risks than in the immediate aftermath
of the Dayton Agreement. In addition, the ceasefire in Bosnia
was declared in winter, which limited the exhumation process,
while the ceasefire in Kosovo came at the height of summer.
The
pattern of killings and burial in Kosovo also differed from
that of Bosnia -Herzegovina and hindered investigations in
that the crime scenes and body disposal points were often
scattered over a radius of several kilometers. Mass graves
in western Kosovo tended to hold fewer bodies than their counterparts
in Bosnia, reflecting the lower volume of killing, but also
the more scattered distribution of remains. Some bodies were
burnt individually, some in groups, while others were transported
in refrigerated trucks to industrial crematoria at meat-processing
plants.
Lessons
from Bosnia-Herzegovina had been learned by both sides. The
Holbrooke-Milosevic agreement of October 1998 gave NATO satellite
and spy planes the right to monitor the situation on the ground,
leading to an increased level of caution on the part of the
perpetrators. One significant departure from Bosnia-Herzegovina
was the widespread use of wells for the disposal of bodies
which, along with the use of grenades to collapse the walls
and landmines to hamper excavation, led to increased difficulties
for investigators. Given the chaotic situation on the ground,
the finite resources of the ICTY, and the rapid onset of winter
which curtailed the exhumation process, ICG personnel were
well placed to support the tribunal with the task of witness
documentation.
The
difficulties of documenting war crimes in a post-conflict
environment should not be under-estimated. The wellbeing of
the witness is of course paramount, and that of the local
staff a close second. Daily field work often entailed attending
mass grave exhumations and reburials, marking newly discovered
bodies with Global Positioning Satellites (GPS), and recording
crime scenes with digital cameras. With a fleet of 15 jeeps,
the ICG focused on the municipalities of Decan/Decani, Gjakova/Djakovica,
Rahovec/Orahovac, Malisheve/Malisevo, Istog/Istok, Suhareke/Suva
Reka and Prizren/Prizren. The international legal staff were
comprised of lawyers, some of whom had worked for the ICTY
in the Hague; while local legal staff were drawn predominately
from the various sub-committees of the Council for the Defence
of Human Rights and Freedoms (CDHRF), the leading Kosovar
human rights NGO. Data base entry was supervised by international
IT support staff and a logistics unit.
While
gathering testimony in remote rural areas, ICG staff encountered
communities that had not been serviced by the international
humanitarian relief net, which was still in its early stages
of development. ICG staff facilitated the delivery of humanitarian
items such as food, clothing, hygiene packs, blankets, and
coffins.
In
conjunction with Médecins Du Monde (MDM) Sweden, a
War Crime Trauma Unit was established through which the services
of psychologists and social workers was offered to witnesses.
Interview training and debriefing sessions were also organised
for local staff members by MDM Sweden, and a lecture series
was conducted with the World Health Organisation (WHO) which
dealt with psycho-social dimensions of rape, preventing mental
distress from becoming a disorder, relaxation techniques,
and rational psychotropic drug use.Close cooperation with
local human rights NGOs in the field made the operation more
effective by utilising local knowledge. This partnership was
reciprocated at the end of the project through the capacity
building donation of laptops, digital cameras, CD ROM writers,
printers, and scanners to 24 local organizations working on
human rights and psycho-social projects.
With
the advent of the International Criminal Court (ICC), this
evolutionary process has the potential to develop still further.
Well managed and resourced NGOs can collect and store testimony
to be interfaced with the data requirements of international
tribunals, and this can be of value to fledgling institutions
which may not be as well funded or resourced as their mandate
would require. The number of conflicts involving gross violations
of humanitarian law and/or human rights abuse does not appear
to be decreasing and thus, while war crime documentation field
studies remain problematic to say the least, the ICG Project
offers a model upon which future projects might be based.
Incorporating
humanitarian aid, psycho-social, and local capacity-building
dimensions into such a documentation project also provides
the testifying communities with tangible benefits, made all
the more important by the fact that, although substantial
bodies of testimony have been amassed, those indicted for
crimes in Kosovo remain at large. A 292-page report based
on the seven months of field research conducted by the project
entitled "Reality Demands" is available from the
ICG web site at www.crisisweb.org
|