August 8, 2008

First Guantanamo War Crimes Trial Ends in Split Verdict and Short Sentence

By Anthony Dworkin

 

Salim Hamdan, the former driver of Osama bin Laden, became the first defendant to be sentenced by the military commissions at Guantanamo Bay on August 7, receiving a sentence of five and a half years for providing material support for terrorism.  The day before, the panel of military officers trying Hamdan had found him guilty of the material support charge, but acquitted him of the more serious charge of conspiracy.

Hamdan will receive credit for the time he has been held since being charged before the military commissions, totalling 61 months (itself a striking indication of how drawn out the trial process at Guantanamo has been).  This means that Hamdan will have completed his sentence by the end of the year. 

However, in a reminder of the extraordinary nature of the Guantanamo regime, Hamdan will not be released when his sentence is completed.  A Pentagon spokesman confirmed on August 5 that he will continue to be classed as an enemy combatant, liable for continued detention unless one of the regular Administrative Review Boards gives clearance for his release.

Hamdan has the right to appeal to a special appeals court, the Court of Military Commissions Review, and then to the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia and the US Supreme Court.  One issue likely to be raised by his lawyers in the review process is whether material support for terrorism constitutes a crime under the laws of war.  The presiding judge ruled that it was a crime under this body of law, but the majority of legal scholars dispute this point.

 

 

Related Chapters from Crimes of War: What the Public Should Know 2.0:

Guantanamo

Terrorism

Related Links:

Military Commissions Home Page

U.S. Department of Defense

Conviction Flawed in First Guantanamo War Crimes Trial

Human Rights First

August 6, 2008

Guilty in Guantanamo

By Stacy Sullivan

Human Rights Watch, August 7, 2008

Why Hamdan's Material Support Convictions Violate the Ex Post Facto Clause

By Kevin Jon Heller

Opinio Juris blog, August 7, 2008

 

Back to Top


This site © Crimes of War Project 1999-2008

The Military Trial of Omar Khadr: Child Soldiers and the Law

March 10, 2008


Plea Bargain Highlights Anomalies of Guantanamo System

April 12, 2007


Supreme Court Overturns Guantanamo Military Tribunal

June 30, 2006


The End of Guantanamo?

May 19, 2006


U.S. Supreme Court to Hear Case on Military Tribunals

November 7, 2005


Military Commissions Set to Resume After Court Ruling on Bin Laden's Driver

July 19, 2005


Three Misconceptions About the Laws of War

October 29, 2004


New Developments on Guantanamo Detainees

December 9, 2003


Law and the Campaign Against Terrorism: The View from the Pentagon

December 16, 2002